innocence blog

A Web log for the Innocence Institute of Point Park University

Wednesday, February 28, 2007

Is it really justice for all?

This article appeared in the Patriot-News on February 20, 2007:

Is it really justice for all?
Gladden case, others show flaws of conforming evidence to crime

By Pete Shellem
The Patriot-News

The homecomings are always surreal.

In Patty Carbone's case, it was a reuniting with her father and brothers, and later with the 21-year-old daughter she hadn't seen outside prison in about a decade.

Steven Crawford's family rented a limo and took him out for a steak dinner before returning to the family members and well-wishers from whom he had been separated for almost three decades.

Barry Laughman was surrounded by the rural roughneck workers that made up his loved ones.
David Gladden was greeted by nieces and nephews he didn't know he had at his grandmother's Harrisburg home Friday night.

She served him the fried chicken he had been telling me about every time I tried to get him to talk about his case.

They were all joyful moments, but in each case I was struck by overwhelming sadness watching these bewildered souls being thrust back into a life from which they were torn when the justice system ran them over.

They were all at a disadvantage when it happened. Patty Carbone was described as trailer trash. Steven Crawford was a young black man in trouble with the law after the racial unrest of the late 1960s.

Like Laughman, Gladden appears to be mentally challenged. At the time of his 1995 trial, a psychologist said he was functioning at a third-grade level.

While authorities dispute whether he's really retarded, one of the first things Gladden wanted to talk about to me, his attorney Royce L. Morris, and his grandmother when we picked him up from the State Correctional Institution at Mahanoy was the fact that the Cartoon Network had started showing reruns of the old Hanna-Barbara cartoon "Lippy the Lion and Hardy Har Har."
And when I first started writing about Gladden more than a year ago, Steven Crawford -- who was also housed at Mahanoy -- told me Gladden once showed up in the showers wearing a raincoat and boots.

I did write down one thing Gladden said on our three-hour trip from prison Friday:
"The truth of the matter is I still don't know what's going on."

But then again, perhaps he wasn't the only one during this long and sorry case of injustice.
The arson investigators who probed M. Geneva Long's murder initially blamed faulty wiring for the blaze that was set to cover up her death.

Never mind the piles of magazines and papers on top of her body.

It was clear from their reports that they initially suspected Andrew Dillon, staying in a room next door, who would later admit to killing four other elderly women in a similar manner.

Yet, they were led away from those suspicions by a convicted sex offender named Donald "Goofball" Walborn, who met Gladden in prison. At the time, Walborn was facing charges for raping a 12-year-old girl.

In his initial statement, Walborn described Gladden as a Superfly kind of guy, flashing jewelry and money after Long's murder, although it was clear that Long had nothing of value to steal and Gladden couldn't even raise the $100 he needed to get out of jail on a marijuana possession charge.

While on bail for a rape charge, Walborn proceeded to rape another 12-year-old. Within days of being let out of prison last year, he was arrested on charges that he molested a 19-year-old retarded man. Those charges were thrown out, but when the stories came out, Walborn would later accuse me of molesting him. This was the "reliable confidential informant" police used -- a man who referred to himself as "the eyes and ears of the Harrisburg Police Department."

Walborn also implicated a small-time burglar named James A. Carson Jr., who eventually confessed and said he was burglarizing Long's apartment with Gladden and saw Gladden choking her as he ran away.

Police proceeded with this theory even though Carson identified the wrong location, put himself with Gladden when Gladden was in jail, and couldn't even say whether Long was white or black in his initial statements.

Since he was the only witness, I immediately sought out Carson when I began investigating the case. He recanted right away and said he had been coerced into the confession.

I covered Gladden's 1995 trial and was surprised at the verdict, since Carson was the only witness against him. Afterward, I was at a bar with Gladden's attorney, Allen C. Welch, who was railing about the outcome -- first-degree murder and a life sentence. His trial folder was on the bar and I started to page through it. On the first page, Welch had written, "Can I blame Andrew Dillon?"

When I asked what Dillon -- who at the time had been charged in one murder and was the prime suspect in three others -- had to do with it, Welch told me Dillon lived nearby. He said then-District Attorney John F. Cherry had told him authorities had cleared Dillon.

When I later asked Cherry about it, he said they cleared Dillon with polygraphs.

It wasn't until years later when I looked at the case again that I found Dillon had refused a polygraph and Carson had flunked.

So why didn't authorities turn back?

Thomas Carter, the city detective who solved the Dillon case, was telling everyone who would listen that they had the wrong man in Long's murder.

Carter wouldn't talk to me about the case, but he told a Susquehanna High School forensics class I spoke to last year that my stories were on the mark.

When Dauphin County District Attorney Edward M. Marsico Jr. and his first assistant, Fran Chardo, first retrieved the Gladden file, they knew there were major problems.

The file, which they opened to me, had crime-scene photos from Dillon's other murders in it, along with a fax about Dillon's arrest from Carter to Cherry. They were also troubled that a murder trial transcript was only about an inch-and-a-half thick. To their credit, they immediately began conducting an exhaustive review, but there was little with which to work.

The only solid piece of evidence The Patriot-News' series turned up was a witness who said Dillon asked him for an alibi on the night of the slaying. Joseph Baumgartner's statement was corroborated by one Dillon gave police after the murder, in which he said he was with a heavyset white cabdriver named Joe at the time of Long's murder.

Last Thursday, Marsico and Chardo told me to expect some news. But then they hooked Baumgartner up to the lie detector and he failed. He admitted to Morris that he may have embellished the story, but stuck to his guns about Dillon asking for an alibi.

Marsico took the file home with him Thursday night, reviewed it again, and finally decided to pull the plug, saying Long's murder was a signature of Andrew Dillon. Marsico said any reasonable jury would have acquitted Gladden had they known about Dillon.

"The re-investigation has established to our satisfaction that Andrew Dillon was the principal actor in the murder of Margaret Geneva Long," Marsico and Chardo wrote in the petition that freed Gladden.

State Sen. Stewart Greenleaf has formed an innocence commission to review the 10 cases where DNA proved people were doing time for crimes they didn't commit.

Of the four cases I've investigated and written about in the past decade, only Barry Laughman's will be among those 10 because there was fresh DNA evidence.

But there has been a common theme in all of the cases -- investigators trying to conform the evidence to their theories rather than the other way around.

As one state police investigator has always told me, "you can't prove innocence."

Hopefully, the justice system will come up with better ways to assure guilt before it unjustly swallows another large chunk of someone's life.


  • At 8:38 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    Classifieds for our community. Buy, sell, trade, date, events... post anything. Adquity Classifieds.

  • At 9:25 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    Classifieds for our community. Buy, sell, trade, date, events... post anything. Adquity Classifieds.

  • At 11:30 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    Where is the protection in civil aspect of it? I would love to know. Where our children are concerned. How can our state of TX take your children or a child away with no abuse, neglect, or drugs? Us as parents are convicted of a crime and pay the price we are not innocent until proven guilty. Its all about who has the better attorney! Where is the justice in that? You are sentenced and receive the punishment of having your child taken away from you and your still fighting. Not only the emotions the parents go through but what are our sweet precious children going through? Where is the justice in that. Is Lady Justice the balance of equality is her blind fold on? It is a shame. I really am disappointed in our legal system and what goes on. I would love to have the resources to fight for our children's rights. And giving protection for this not to happen any longer to innocent men and women and first most the children. Any suggestions?

  • At 5:16 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    It's not always about the better attorney. If you are an attorney, where you have a strong arm, over zealous District Attorney that throws the book at everyone regardless... one that will bully you if you don't accept his plea "deals".. If you stand up to this Texas D.A. he'll make sure that all of your defendant's suffer and you'll never get a better deal ever! It's sad that One man can have that much power.. But this is Texas - The home of the good ol boy network.... Anyone interested in unseating a D.A. that has abused his authority for over 15 years? Come to Johnson County, Texas- we'll support you!!!

  • At 9:05 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

  • At 1:09 PM, Anonymous biglinmarshall said…

    The problem is that of course there are going to be mistakes made from time to time, especially when you take into account the complexity of much of the evidence.

    Even so, aren't these people glad that they spent time in prison for crimes they didn't commit rather than being wrongly executed?

  • At 6:57 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said… Rear side, yorkeconomic waterbury igbavboa chuquicamata jordache discoursed hereby strategene

  • At 7:06 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said… book cited during purim trileptal treatment bipolar creams with vitamin a tulasi extract essence in india [url=]b vitamin food sources[/url] acai berrys dont work most absorbed for of vitamin e chox vitamins vitamin c vitamin e [url=]discount nutritional vitamins[/url] clotting vitamin k liver vitamins for inflamed skin depression and vitamins b puitan pride vitamins [url=]echinacea leaf[/url] donepezil aricept vitamin c graduation radio version eyesight nutrition vitamin b12 liquid nutrition vitamins of rickets [url=]bleeding gums vitamins[/url] are centrum vitamins during pregnancy harmful vitamin c infusion dose canadian wholesale vitamins vitamin d-3 deficient symptoms [url=]100 pure liquid vitamin e[/url] can u od on vitamin c vitamin d and air hunger daily dose of vitamin d acai 100 genesis today [url=]folic acid and deficiency and symptoms[/url] does folic acid cause weight gain detrol la dose of 8mg do vitamins help with parkinsons disease dynamic health acai [url=]china vitamin makers[/url] dilantin test results health yourself vitamins cytoxan aloxi levaquin prednisone [url=]children overdosing on vitamins[/url] drug called aricept bleeding depakote rectal combivent boehringer digoxin toxicity symptoms [url=]essential vitamins for men over 40[/url] employment drug screens strattera simple test for vitamin c dr don colbert vitamins rexall sublingual b 12 vitamins [url=]folic acid hearts[/url]

  • At 4:12 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    sanofi acomplia [url=]where to buy acomplia [/url] purchase zimulti acomplia rimonabant

  • At 9:43 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    Is there a physical address where someone might be able to write to and obtain information about this program?

  • At 9:45 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    Is there a physical address where I might write to get additional information about this program?

  • At 11:02 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    livesexSydney Escorts

    A grassroots network of people interested in finding Laura has been growing, and many people who have not met Laura have joined the campaign to find her. Fans of the Find Laura Vogel Facebook Page continue to build community around Laura, even in her absence:

  • At 12:24 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    UK Escortssalvia divinorum extract

    You just made my day. I was researching a paper for lawschool when I came upon your article. It's amazing that those who have had so much happen to them to make them bitter and vindictive are typically the ones that don't hold a grudge and forgive so easily. I'm amazed by this person's fortitude and strength. I hope he has a wonderful life. Thanks for writing the great article.

  • At 10:48 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    Vegas Escortprodutos eroticos

    Since 1998, investigative series by Shellem, a longtime reporter for the Patriot-News of Harrisburg , Pennsylvania , have highlighted grave flaws with those homicide convictions that eventually prompted the state to set all four people free.

  • At 12:04 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    Launching Sphero has been a roller-coaster ride. And while we’re still screaming along with our hands in the air, we are excited to announce that Sphero is in stock. Pre-orders have been fulfilled and those who order now won’t have to wait for Sphero to ship.
    vibrators for womendanske pornopiger

  • At 4:44 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    buy valium buy diazepam nz - diazepam online australia

  • At 6:15 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    Howdy buy cialis - www.cialis coupon

  • At 8:07 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    clomid vs hcg | buying clomid online - buy clomid on line, clomid day 2-6

  • At 6:26 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    getting pregnant clomid | can you buy clomid over the counter - where can i buy clomid in the uk, ovulation after clomid days 5 9

  • At 6:53 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    progesterone levels after ovulation on clomid | cheap clomid without prescriptions - clomid without rx, ovulation on clomid 5-9

  • At 3:57 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    iui clomid twins | - clomid prices, clomid 150 mg success

  • At 6:02 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    clomid 100mg days 5 9 success stories | [url=]buy clomid pct[/url] - buy clomid 100mg uk, kksh when do you start clomid

  • At 4:25 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    ovulation after taking clomid | - purchase clomid no prescription, clomid first round success

  • At 5:02 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    buy generic viagra , buy generic viagra online

  • At 5:46 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    clomid hot flashes | - ordering clomid online safe, uses for clomid

  • At 4:53 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    clomid experiences | clomid for sale no prescription - clomid 25 mg, long term effects of clomid

  • At 6:08 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    clomid pct dose | [url=]clomid prescription[/url] - cheap clomid online, jxtq clomid and fsh

  • At 11:56 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    fertility clomid | clomid without a prescription - clomid 50 mg for men, clomid and triplets

  • At 7:54 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    clomid while on cycle | [url=]how to get clomid without a prescription[/url] - buy generic clomid, wuut clomid pct protocol

  • At 5:05 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    [url=]Where to buy Cheap Inderal With No Prescription

    No Prescription
    The Most Trusted Online Drug Supplier
    Fast Worldwide Delivery
    Cheapest prices for Inderal

    inderal dosages
    buy name brand inderal
    what is inderal prescribed for
    inderal la erectile dysfunction
    mixing inderal and amitrypiline
    Inderal information

    [url=]inderal la medicine
    what is inderal prescribed for
    inderal shots
    inderal for anxiety reviews
    side effects if inderal la

  • At 6:01 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    [url=]Buy Discount Celebrex Online No prescription! Discount Pharmacy[/url] Buy Discount Celebrex Online No prescription! Discount Pharmacy Buy Discount Celebrex Online No prescription! Discount Pharmacy
    [url=]Buy Cheap Cipro tablets Online No prescription![/url] Buy Cheap Cipro tablets Online No prescription! Buy Cheap Cipro tablets Online No prescription!
    [url=]Order Cheap Diflucan tablets Online No prescription! Discount Pharmacy[/url] Order Cheap Diflucan tablets Online No prescription! Discount Pharmacy Order Cheap Diflucan tablets Online No prescription! Discount Pharmacy
    [url=]Buy Discount Keflex tablets Online No prescription! Free Delivery[/url] Buy Discount Keflex tablets Online No prescription! Free Delivery Buy Discount Keflex tablets Online No prescription! Free Delivery


Post a Comment

<< Home