innocence blog

A Web log for the Innocence Institute of Point Park University

Friday, April 20, 2007

New York police commisioner orders forensic shakeup

This article appeared in the New York Times on April 20, 2007:

After Falsified Test Results, Kelly Orders Forensic Shakeup

By Thomas J. Lueck

With the disclosure that two civilian employees reported false results in testing drug bags in 2002 at the police crime laboratory, Police Commissioner Raymond W. Kelly has ordered a shakeup of the Forensic Investigations Division and the creation of an oversight panel, the authorities said yesterday.

The changes come as a rebuke to the forensic unit’s former commander, Deputy Chief Denis McCarthy, who was recently transferred to a patrol division.

Chief McCarthy, a 27-year veteran of the department, was in charge in 2002 when the two employees were found to have engaged in “dry-labbing,” or cutting corners in the process of testing for drugs during an internal integrity test conducted by the department. In addition, the forensics unit failed to report the transgression to state officials and to a national laboratory accreditation board, as it is required to do.

Chief McCarthy’s transfer and the 2002 drug testing falsification were reported yesterday by The New York Post. Mr. Kelly said that Inspector Kevin J. Walsh, formerly of the Counter-Terrorism Bureau, had replaced Chief McCarthy as commander of the forensics division.

A spokesman for the Police Department, Paul J. Browne, said the falsified test results in 2002 had no bearing on actual court cases, since they were revealed in a routine procedure of “blind proficiency tests” designed as internal checks on the integrity and competence of civilian criminalists, 100 of whom are now employed by the crime laboratory.

But some critics are not convinced that it is an isolated incident. Peter Neufeld, a lawyer and co-founder of the Innocence Project, a New York-based legal group that uses DNA evidence to represent people it believes have been wrongly convicted, said it was unclear how many cases were affected in New York and elsewhere by such falsified lab work.

Mr. Browne said the department’s own testing revealed that the two employees had tried to save time by failing to inspect the contents of all the bags believed to hold cocaine, and reporting that they had tested them all. One technician, or criminalist, was told to inspect 37 bags and reported that all contained cocaine, even though four did not. The other criminalist said all six bags contained cocaine, but one did not.

The case was handled by the Internal Affairs Division, and both employees were disciplined in accordance with police policy, Mr. Browne said. But the violation of department rules came when the forensic unit failed to file a report on the matter with both the state and with the American Society of Criminal Laboratory Directors/Laboratory Accreditation Board, a national oversight organization that accredits New York state forensic labs.

“Our own testing worked, but the lapse came in failing to notify,” Mr. Browne said. He said notification would be one of several procedures studied by a new Forensic Science Review Committee being formed with four senior police officials and two civilian forensic scientists.
But the creation of an oversight panel made up mainly of police personnel does not go far enough, Mr. Neufeld said. He added, “Whenever you have a scandal like this, it is essential to bring in an independent entity without any possibility of conflicts of interest.”

Mr. Browne said the 2002 violations had come under renewed scrutiny last month after the current civilian director of the crime lab, Dr. Peter Pizzola, was informed by state officials of an anonymous report that someone in a crime laboratory at an unspecified location was dry-labbing. When he asked about past violations by New York City criminalists, Dr. Pizzola, who was not with the division in 2002, learned that there had been cases that year that were not reported outside the department.

The police said that Dr. Pizzola’s predecessor, W. Mark Dale, had maintained in a recent interview that he believed the violations should not have been reported outside the department because they were being handled by Internal Affairs.

Mr. Browne said that one employee responsible for the 2002 violations, Elizabeth Mansour, had retired, and that the other, Rameschandra J. Patel, had been suspended from crime lab work and restricted to answering telephones.


  • At 7:49 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    Can anyone recommend the top Script Deployment program for a small IT service company like mine? Does anyone use or How do they compare to these guys I found recently: N-able N-central event management
    ? What is your best take in cost vs performance among those three? I need a good advice please... Thanks in advance!

  • At 3:28 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    ups sorry delete plz [url=].[/url]

  • At 3:34 PM, Anonymous viagra online said…

    Hi, I really like your blog but I can't check it every day to see if you posted something new, so I'd like to know if there is a way to subscribe to your blog

  • At 4:21 PM, Anonymous Ruth Miller said…

    Please distribute this information to those who may be interested in
    supporting this important project.

    ruth AT

    Thank you!



    Imagine being caged - forever - having contact only with people who would
    just as soon knife you as say hello. Imagine that fear ... for the rest of
    your days ... just because someone was certain they saw you somewhere that
    you'd never even been.

    Now imagine yourself saving another human being from that doomed existence.

    That's one gripping perspective of the seven dramatic stories in Mind
    Mysteries Hidden Object Game. Feel the desperation of the wrongly accused,
    the despair of the crime victims and the determination of both the
    prosecuting and defense attorneys. Identify with the victories of freeing
    the wrongly accused and bringing the real criminals to justice.

    As you play Mind Mysteries you will learn how the brain works, how the eye
    deceives and what scientists, attorneys and social workers are doing to
    change the laws governing eye witness testimony in capital cases. Today most
    jurors believe that eyewitness testimony is among the most reliable evidence
    presented in criminal trials. (It's actually among the least reliable.)

    This game is multi-layered with neuroscience experiments, passionate back
    stories and detailed analysis of social and legal issues.

    The characters are based on real-life people: the wrongly accused, the
    eye-witnesses stepping up for justice, and the horrendously damaged victims
    of crime. All of these people are heroes with real life struggles and
    extraordinary circumstances to overcome. You'll want to get to know them, to
    learn their stories. We want to share that with you.

  • At 10:48 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    Vegas Escortprodutos eroticos

    At 46, Shellem is a journalistic throwback: a chain-smoking, B-movie reporter who meets sources in bars and immerses himself in his subject. He tirelessly pores over court files searching for nuggets overlooked, in some cases, even by defense lawyers: Altered lab reports. A police informant with a shady past. A previously unknown witness.

  • At 3:58 PM, Anonymous Denver DUI Attorney said…

    It is unfortunate when labs do not comply with ethical duties to notify prosecutors of problems at the lab. It is equally scary when the prosecutor fails to provide the evidence in violation of Brady. I cannot imagine how many people had their lives torn apart because of this lab work.

  • At 6:41 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    thank you very much for share
    noveller for ungeEscorts Directory

  • At 3:51 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

  • At 5:30 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    thanks for your blog
    MAX's sex filmblog dating

  • At 7:08 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    buy alprazolam online without prescription xanax generic form - xanax lethal dose

  • At 3:26 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    online xanax buy xanax online canada - xanax dosage .5

  • At 11:51 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    [b][url=][/url][/b] He grew up in Paris and also a solitary of his to start with positions was with the Folies Bergere. In case you seriously don know, the Folies Bergere is actually a man or woman in the past vestiges still left of preceding Paris, and is particularly as well-liked at this moment due to the fact it at any time was. The Folies are renowned for his or her modern functions and has highlighted the pretty Josephine Baker and Charlie Chaplin features inside the previous.

    [b][url=]ugg boots[/url][/b] Different varieties of automobile insurance readily available can get bewildering. You will need to look at the vehicle insurance protection estimates given to you from the insurance protection organizations and choose what your automobile insurance high quality should really be by considering your individual finances. Usually, a vehicle insurance plan top quality depends on variables similar to the classification of one's car or truck, what your driving background is, your own private driving experience, your occupation, your gender as well as your age.

    [b][url=]uggs on alse[/url][/b] Leather handbags are frequently seemed upon as an effective fashion statement for socialites particularly women of all ages. In addition getting a rare and 1st course accessory for just a lady's clothes, leather handbags can also be ready to fit a spread of professions. Like, a leather-based purse could be featured to be a tote bag, a travel bag, a shoulder bag, messenger bags, laptop computer notebook bags, discount purses, company handbags etcetera.

    [b][url=]ugg boots outlet[/url][/b] Even when you amongst those individuals who actually can pay awareness if they appear to be preoccupied with other issues, preserving eye get in touch with is going to be worthy of your while. Don just concentrate, but be certain one other particular person knows that you having to pay attention. And eye make contact with would be the traditional method to display it..

    [b][url=][/url][/b] As being the resale marketplace will become much more successful, it will exert an increasing number of upward cost stress as well as the costs will go up! We have found a significant influence inside the resorts wherein we have been included. Nearly all of the truly reduced priced timeshares have previously resold. It really is like harvesting apples.

  • At 11:02 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    Once we consider the concept of the phrase adore, with terms of an amorous romance utilizing one other, nonetheless like a experience that is engendered when you have miltchmonkey an improved association with yourself very : or simply for a a feeling of larger unity with your loved ones and also humanity * that will become a lot more magnificent that someone is looking for to have will be adore.

  • At 1:02 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    Hyland's forethought and own sense of personal style created the product. north face jackets Basically, we making them to order, so if you want one you need to do so by 5:00pm the 9th of December 2012. uggs on sale Amoruso was an early e-tail pioneer in the social media arena, using word-of-mouth and social platforms exclusively to build her brand and communicate with customers and fans. ghd straightener I subsisted on almost nothing but sugar, fat, and white flour for the next 48 hours. north face canada Of course the CG isn the greatest, and that always has the nasty tendency to pull back a disbelief-suspension layer.

  • At 4:07 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    TweetClassic, Color and Cut. ugg uk While upscale, the Chadwick Bell woman went on her adventure in coats, short skirts and dresses, in jersey, wool and jacquard, with black, gold and green being the predominant colours for fall here.. If you have dark eyes, then FreshLook ColorBlends' Green, or Durasoft 2 Colors Green, Acuvue 2 Colors Jade Green can do wonders.. north face backpacks Lurex fabrics and fashions began turning heads back in the 60's and 70's when designers such as Rudi Gernreich, Oscar de la Renta, Yves Saint Laurant and later Giannini Versace and Philippe Gaultier traded sequins for the flashy threads of Lurex. In many ways, it typifies what San Francisco is all about - a haven for the enquiring and liberal mind, and sure if the architecture looks a little bit run down then what of it? Aren't the people only great? And isn't the city only one of the most individual in the world?

  • At 4:59 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    The book is designed to maximise accessibility of the text for the reader. cheap north face jackets I only hope that Anna reads this review and considers producing another book, or perhaps a website or, even better, a course, within which she could share much more of her preferred techniques. uggs Totally disrespectful. Most people have had negative customer service experiences with large brands, and PublikDemand is trying to give those consumers a course of action aside from waiting on the phone for a manager or posting negative reviews on Yelp. ugg A majority of the youngsters wear these contact lenses.

  • At 6:52 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    Someday I hope to be successful enough to where I can start my own scholarship foundation for those who want to succeed and go forward with their goals and ambitions. north face sale Pinterest has, in fact, been so effective for retailers, manyfashion retailersare managing Pinterest accountsin addition to Facebook and Twitter.. Square Enix online store has revealed the French release day of the highly anticipated Kingdom Hearts 3D: Dream, Drop, Distance. ghd straighteners My cat meows and i hear him talking to me. ghd Remember that 'quintessentially Carrie' moment in the Sex and the City movie where she tried on dress after designer wedding dress for a Vogue photoshoot? Well, her Lanvin 20s-style, flapper-inspired wedding dress is on display for everyone to see in this exhibit.

  • At 7:45 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    I don know any woman who wouldn welcome a Hermes bag into her wardrobe. north face canada This recipe uses kangaroo fillet and it is usually bought in a vacuum packed tray. ghd This picture shows the view facing East towards El Cajon. ugg boots Susan has studied Art at the Art Students League where she currently teaches a summer session and teaches Drawing Painting course through out the year at The Art Center of Northern New Jersey. ugg sale The face beneath the mask is obviously that of Bruce Wayne, but one of a different era.

  • At 9:46 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    It's transparent to me. ghd hair straighteners Plus Karl created a two for one bag; a large Fendi bag with a baguette attached to it.. BIOGRAPHY interviewed Calvin, his wife, daughter and associates like Vogue's Anna Wintour and Harper Bazaar's Liz Tiberis to profile America's most famous fashion designer. Some of the best fashion design schools are in the mid-price range.. uggs canada Photography differs by the virtue of the work itself.

  • At 10:50 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    He went through chemo treatments, radiation, and two bone marrow extractions (because the first one arrived late to the lab and spoiled), then one marrow reinsertion. north face backpacks He opened Vis-a-Vis The Salon in 2001 in the Buckhead community with a vision of superior customer service. are encouraged to play the game with their children and for parents to teach their kids online safety. ghd hair A good cap can change a standard ensemble into an excellent a single. north face jackets on sale Present at the ceremony were Catherine, Edward Calvert, George Richmond, Frederick Tatham and John Linnell.

  • At 7:37 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    (Dolan) shouldn't be mad at me because all I did was come before him and play the hardest and the best I could do. Shoppers will be able to peruse unique gifts ranging from fine art, quality crafts, jewelry and accessories to pottery, photography, clothing and specialty foods. I have had people hugging me on the streets in the last few days in Toronto, for making the film I have. uggs on sale At only 25 seconds in length, the teaser doesn give us much, but it still a good look at what to expect also, it includes a short clip of B baby bump during her pregnancy, so everyone can finally quiet down about that whole Beyoncé-wasn conspiracy. north face sale Chanel purses are inevitable accessories for many elegant ladies.

  • At 12:14 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    If you would like to help, I will certainly put you in touch with them. ghd hair straighteners Do not say I disturb your work, I just want you to make a phone call to you. north face jackets on sale Narrative fiction, dramaturgy, the moving image and the cinematic montage collectively form a great medium of appropriating these ideas. north face uk Trail-blazing K-pop girl group 2NE1, made up of 4 distinct individuals CL, DARA, BOM and MINZY will bemaking a stop here for their 2NE1 Global Tour- New Evolution concert on 8 Dec 2012, 8.30pm, at Stadium Malawati. Pondering of this, I really feel so thrilled, we sure to have a sexy and excited Christmas..

  • At 5:13 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    Some indicators, however, reinforce the impression that Blake illustrations as a whole that they disagree with the accompanying text: In the margin of Homer With Sword and his companions, Blake notes, "Every thing in Dantes Comedia do see that tyrannical purposes that has made this world of all Foundation and the Goddess of nature and not the Holy Spirit." Blake seems to dissent from Dante admiration of the poetic works of the ancient Greeks, and the apparent joy with which Dante assigns punishment in hell (as evidenced by the somber mood of the song). Online degree learning has made having your degree far more easy because you can easily earn your degree from the comfort of your abode and when you finish from work. ghd sale It safer to have the Warehouse in the hands of people who seem and insignificant to the outside observer. on Body Glove BGIPHONE4 Original Flex Case with Clip and Kickstand iPhone 4S/4G Verizon Sprint AT Factory New In Body Glove Retail Package Holder Retail Packaging BlackJoanna Daneman on →★☆Wolfgang Puck 4-Cup Continuous-Flow Food Processor with Overload Protection. ghd hair straightener But there's always the risk of going home with far less than the dealer offered - or even empty-handed..

  • At 6:18 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    It best to go out of your drive to research these rare gems, sinse you source Chanel Handbags For Sale, tote bags and purses on the market great websites at non recourse. north face uk Well, yesterday Dior announced that Raf Simons, who designed for Jil Sander, will be taking the helm as Dior's newest head designer.. north face outlet The China Town mall has been updated and looks kind of cool (if not a bit barren) but otherwsie I haven seen anything in the public areas of the Valley updated since I lived here. north face jackets on sale He describes Walther as unbelievably brilliant technologist, one of the deepest platform thinkers I ever worked with. north face ClickCare .

  • At 3:22 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    Everyone says they can help you lose weight in weeks, days even. Further, the loose ends of one's laces may be inserted in & around your shoes, in order to avoid them ever coming in the way phen375 it is important before you consider buying reductil that you consult your gp as treatment is only available on a prescription basis. Following my true passion, my Core Desire, has opened more doors than I ever dreamed possible. I have lost the identical volume of weight inside past but now my thighs are an inch smaller than they've ever been since I've tracked my measurements if you lift exactly the same amount of weight every time, your body will not get any stronger and will adapt by shrinking muscles you're not using. Matter and molecules flow in and out, casting themselves into its complexities [url=]phen375[/url] the entire guide has ended 100 pages long, along with the unique thing about it ebook is always that it teaches you the way burning fat fast using the most time efficient methods.

  • At 10:53 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    [url=]amoxicillin 500 mg liquid form
    [/url]can you buy amoxicillin over the counter
    amoxicillin mg weight
    amoxicillin 500mg 3 times a day

  • At 9:15 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    Very First, grab their notice! Feel oF all wiFespreaF approaches men anF women strategy other inFiviFuals For joint venture[url=]Louis Vuitton Outlet[/url]
    Then, make your give Fiverse! IF most people else is senFing their gives by way oF electronic mail, ship yours by using stanFarF mail. IF normal mail is extremely usually maFe use oF, use FeFEx.

  • At 11:57 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    It is the valuable answer
    You are not right. Let's discuss it.
    Likely is not present
    I consider, that you are not right. I can defend the position. Write to me in PM.
    What useful question

    [url=][b]michael kors outlet online[/b][/url]
    [url=][b]michael kors outlet online[/b][/url]
    [url=][b]michael kors outlet online[/b][/url]
    [url=][b]michael kors outlet online[/b][/url]
    [url=][b]michael kors outlet online[/b][/url]

  • At 10:48 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    tramadol online no prescription buy tramadol online saturday delivery - tramadol and alcohol

  • At 2:11 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    buy tramadol mastercard buy tramadol online without a prescription - order tramadol online without prescription

  • At 7:43 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    Good post. I certainly love this site. Stick
    with it!

    Take a look at my site ... tao of badass

  • At 4:05 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    Hey there ӏ am so grateful I found yοur website,
    I really found you by aсciԁent, while І was loоκing on Yahoo
    foг something else, Regаrdlesѕ I am heгe nοw and would just
    liκe to say cheeгs for a tremendous post and а all round
    inteгesting blog (I also loѵe thе theme/design), I ԁon't have time to read through it all at the moment but I have bookmarked it and also added your RSS feeds, so when I have time I will be back to read much more, Please do keep up the superb job.

    Also visit my web blog -

  • At 8:30 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    I thinκ the aԁmin of this ωeb site іs really workіng hard іn ѕuppοгt of his wеb ρagе, because here
    everу stuff іs quаlity based stuff.

    My ωеb ѕitе facebook cuenta gratis

  • At 2:29 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    buy tramadol with mastercard buy tramadol no prescription - order tramadol online mastercard

  • At 4:30 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    generic cytotec misoprostol - buy cytotec over counter - buy misoprostol online in india

  • At 7:44 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    buy tramadolultram buy tramadol ultram - where to buy tramadol online

  • At 2:58 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    buy tramadolwithout prescriptions order tramadol online - buy tramadol without prescription

  • At 10:58 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

  • At 2:54 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

  • At 5:43 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    Ні! I know thіs is somewhаt οff topiс but I was wonԁering ωhich blog platform агe
    you using for this ѕite? І'm getting tired of Wordpress because I've had problems with
    hackers and I'm looking at alternatives for another platform. I would be fantastic if you could point me in the direction of a good platform.

    Also visit my web blog: facebook cuenta gratis

  • At 11:36 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    buy ambien france where buy ambien - order ambien online mastercard

  • At 7:24 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    Mаgnifіcent web ѕіte. Plenty of helpful informаtіon here.
    I'm sending it to a few friends ans additionally sharing in delicious. And naturally, thank you in your effort!

    my web-site ... crear facebook gratis

  • At 12:42 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    Μу bгοther гeсommеndеd І might
    like this blοg. He wаѕ totally right.
    Thiѕ post trulу madе my ԁаy.
    You саnn't imagine just how much time I had spent for this information! Thanks!

    my web-site: crear facebook

  • At 6:10 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    Another available treatment option that can be done at home without
    a prescription is a topical ointment. This article may be
    freely reprinted or distributed in its entirety in any ezine, newsletter, blog
    or website. The skin tags will be cut with a method that is in accordance with their location on the body and size.

    Feel free to surf to my site :: natural cure for skin tags

  • At 12:12 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

  • At 8:49 PM, Blogger oakleyses said…

  • At 9:03 PM, Blogger oakleyses said…

  • At 9:14 PM, Blogger oakleyses said…

  • At 9:17 PM, Blogger oakleyses said…

  • At 5:09 AM, Blogger Sara Deever said…

    I just read this article and can say that it is one of the best posts that I read yet. I will appreciate your hard work that you did to share this precious post.

    harrisburg pa investigator


Post a Comment

<< Home